Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant menu

15 dishes across 5 sections $20 to $30 Italian Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 1 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 2 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 3 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 4 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 5 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 6 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 7 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 8 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 9 Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant photo menu 10

WINERY Wine Btl 11 dishes

  • MACKINAC RED Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MALBEC Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • SWEET RED Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MICHIGAN PEACH Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • CHARDONNAY Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • PINOT GRIGIO Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • LATE HARVEST Mackinac Island Winery RIESLING Btl $26.95

  • ROSE SUNSET Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MICHIGAN CHERRY Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • LIGHTHOUSE RED Mackinac Island Winwery Btl $26.95

  • SWEET RIESLING Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

PapaZo 16 dishes

  • CYO 12in Pizza ZO $17.95

  • CYO 16in Pizza ZO $21.95

  • Margherita 12in ZO $18.95

  • Margherita 16in ZO $21.95

  • BBQ Chicken 12in ZO $21.95

  • BBQ Chicken 16in ZO $23.95

  • Chick Bac Ranch 12in ZO $21.95

  • Chick Bac Ranch 16in ZO $23.95

  • Greek 12in ZO $21.95

  • Greek 16in ZO $23.95

  • Meat Lovers 12in ZO $21.95

  • Meat Lovers 16in ZO $23.95

  • Supreme 12in ZO $21.95

  • Supreme 16in ZO $23.95

  • PapaZo Sig 12in $21.95

  • PapaZo Sig 16in $23.95

Dessert 2 dishes

  • Tiramisu $8.95

    A house speciality. Ladyfingers soaked in espresso and stacked in layers with sweet creamy mascarpone cheese, topped with cocoa

  • Canoli $6.99

    Light pastry filled with a sweet ricotta cheese blend.

Kids Menu 6 dishes

  • Kids Cheese Pizza $11.99

  • Kids Pepp Pizza $11.99

  • Kids Sausage Pizza $11.99

  • Kids Pasta $11.99

  • Kids Lasagna $11.99

  • Kids Cheese Rav $11.99

Sides 6 dishes

  • Potato $4.95

  • Side Veg $4.95

  • Meatballs $5.95

  • Sausage $7.95

  • Chicken $7.95

  • Shrimp $10.95

Entrees 6 dishes

  • Chicken Piccata $29.95

    Tender chicken breasts in a rich lemon and caper butter sauce.

  • Italian Steak

    A mouth watering 12oz steak, perfectly seasoned, chargrilled to your liking and served with pesto on the side.

  • Rosemary Salmon $29.95

    Grilled salmon, sun- dried tomatoes, and pesto cream sauce.

  • Tuscan Chicken $29.95

    Twin chicken breasts sauteed with red peppers, roasted garlic, onions, and topped with a garlic cream sauce.

  • Whitefish $33.95

    Fresh whitefish from the Great Lakes delivered daily, seasoned and broiled or deep-fried to perfection, a Nonna Lisa’s favorite.

  • Cioppino $34.95

    Classic seafood stew of Vongole clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, and whitefish in a delicious tomato and herb broth.

Pasta 16 dishes

  • Lasagna $24.95

    Nonna Lisa's home-made lasagna filled with seasoned beef, ricotta, baked with mozzarella and marinara sauce.

  • Fettucine Alfredo $19.95

    Fettucine al dente, our creamy alfredo sauce.

  • Classic Spaghetti $17.95

    Al dente spaghetti with home made marinara, meat sauce, or meatballs

  • Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina $24.95

    Delicious and tender potato gnocchi, our homemade marinara, and mozzerella cheese baked in a terracotta crock in our wood-fired oven. Topped with fresh basil.

  • Tuscan Shrimp $31.95

    Grilled shrimp, roasted red peppers, roasted garlic, artichoke hearts, and spinach with a creamy white wine sauce over linguine.

  • Cheese Ravioli $25.95

    Ravioli stuffed with five cheeses and our homemade marinara sauce.

  • Seafood Portofino $34.95

    Mussels, vongole clams, shrimp, calamari, and mushrooms tossed with angel hair pasta and a creamy garlic butter wine sauce.

  • Nonna Tuscan Tour $29.95

    A sampling of Nonna's lasagna, fettucine alfredo, and chicken parmigiano.

  • Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo

    Grilled beef medallions drizzled with balsamic glaze and served over fettucine tossed with spinach and gorgonzola alfredo.

  • Chicken Parmigiano $26.95

    Tenderized chicken breast lightly dusted with breadcrumbs and baked with mozzarella and our homemade marinara sauce, served on a bed of spaghetti.

  • Penne Primavera $24.95

    Vegetable di giorno sauteed with penne pasta and tossed in a pesto wine sauce.

  • Gluten Free Ravioli $26.95

    Gluten Free Ravioli stuffed with five cheeses and our homemade marinara sauce.

  • Seafood Risotto $34.95

    Delightful rich seafood risotto of vongole clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, and white wine.

  • Mushroom Risotto $24.95

    Luxurious and creamy risotto made with mushrooms and white wine.

  • Pasta Al Forno MEATSAUCE $22.95

    Baked penne pasta tossed with a hearty meat sauce and topped with mozzarella & parmigiano.

  • Pasta Al Forno ALFREDO $23.95

    Baked penne pasta tossed with creamy Alfredo sauce and topped with mozzarella & parmigiano.

Pizza 8 dishes

  • CYO 12in Pizza $17.95

  • Pizza Margherita $18.95

    A Classic! Tomato sauce, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, and olive oil

  • Pizza Capricciosa $21.95

    Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, prosciutto, and olive oil base.

  • Funghi E Salsicca $21.95

    Mushrooms, sausage, fresh mozzarella and basil, olive oil base.

  • Pizza Romana $19.95

    Our homemade focaccia topped with marinara and fresh mozzarella.

  • Veggie Stromboli $22.95

    Mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, spinach & mozzarella in a golden pizza shell. Served with marinara sauce on the side.

  • Meat Lover's Stromboli $24.95

    Salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage and mozzarella enclosed in a golden pizza shell. Served with marinara on the side.

  • Nonna Lisa's Special Stromboli $26.95

    Italian ham, salami, pepperoni, red onions, mushrooms, and roasted red peppers in a golden pizza shell. A Nonna Lisa's speciality. Served with marinara on the side.

Salads 5 dishes

  • Antipasto Salad

    Crisp greens with julienne salami, prosciutto, ham, roasted red peppers, tomatoes, red onion, and mozzarella.

  • Italian Salad

    Fresh greens with tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, roasted red pepper, mozzarella, peperoncini, topped with marinated grilled chicken.

  • Chicken Caesar Salad $23.95

    Crisp romaine, crunchy croutons, and parmigiano, tossed with Tuscan caesar dressing and topped with marinated grilled chicken.

  • Garden Salad

    Fresh greens tossed with tomatoes, cucumber, red onions, and croutons.

  • Caesar Salad $14.99

Appetizers 9 dishes

  • Antipasto Plate $24.95

    Sun-dried and marinated tomatoes, artichoke hearts, kalamata olives, a roasted garlic bulb, fresh mozzarella, hard salami and pepperoni served with baked focaccia.

  • Basket Breadsticks $9.95

    A basket with six of Nonna Lisa's famous breadsticks

  • Bruschetta $14.95

    Baked ciabatta slices topped with a traditional mixture of tomato, fresh basil, and olive oil.

  • Calamari $24.95

    Fresh calamari rings lightly fried with our seasoned flour and dusted with parmigiano. Served with lemon and our marinara sauce.

  • Fried Ravioli $19.95

    Cornmeal dusted and deep fried four cheese ravioli, served with our marinara sauce.

  • Mussels Napoli $19.95

    Blue mussels in the shell, simmered in white wine, garlic, butter, and red onion. Served with lemon.

  • Arancini $15.95

    Delicious deep fried balls of arborio rice with a mozzarella cheese filling and delightfully crunchy coating, Served with marinara.

  • Mozzarella Moons $16.95

    Deep fried mozzarella cheese hlaf moons dusted with Italian bread crumbs and served with marinara.

  • Focaccia $14.95

    Thick, delicious and perfectly seasoned homemade foccacia bread.

Wine Bottle MIW 11 dishes

  • MACKINAC RED Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MALBEC Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • SWEET RED Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MICHIGAN PEACH Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • CHARDONNAY Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • PINOT GRIGIO Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • LATE HARVEST Mackinac Island Winery RIESLING Btl $26.95

  • ROSE SUNSET Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • MICHIGAN CHERRY Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

  • LIGHTHOUSE RED Mackinac Island Winwery Btl $26.95

  • SWEET RIESLING Mackinac Island Winery Btl $26.95

Beer Bottle 6 dishes

  • Bud Light Bottle $6.50

  • Michelob Ultra Bottle $6.50

  • Peroni Bottle $6.50

  • Corona Bottle $6.50

  • Angry Orchard Bottle $6.50

  • Founders All Day IPA Bottle $6.50

Beverage 1 dishes

  • 2-Liter Soda $5.95

To-Go Cocktail 6 dishes

  • Northern Lights $12.99

    Tequila, Midory, Blue Curacao, Lemonade, Lemon-Lime Soda.

  • Red Sky At The Night $12.99

    Vodka, Cranberry, Pineapple, Lemon-Lime Soda.

  • Mackinaw Sunset $12.99

    Coconut Rum, Peach Snnaps, Orange Juice, Cherry Syrup.

  • Great Lakes $12.99

    Coconut rum, Dark Rum, Blue Curacao, Lemonade

  • Michigan Storm $12.99

    Bourboun, Triple sec, Mango, Lemonade, Club soda.

  • Peach Sangria $12.99

    Peach Wine, Fruit Juices.

UNCATEGORIZED 1 dishes

  • Charge $0.01

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Located in the heart of Mackinaw City, Michigan, Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant brings a cozy and welcoming Italian dining experience to visitors looking for comforting flavors and a relaxed atmosphere. Sitting at 312 S Huron Ave, this local favorite has the kind of warm energy that makes people slow down and enjoy a good meal without feeling rushed. From the moment you walk in, the restaurant gives off a classic Italian vibe, blending casual comfort with a touch of old-school charm. During warmer days, the outdoor seating area becomes a great spot to enjoy lunch or dinner while taking in the lively surroundings of the city.

The menu leans into traditional Italian-style dining, offering hearty dishes that pair perfectly with a glass of wine or a refreshing cocktail. Whether someone is stopping by for a full dine-in experience or grabbing takeout after exploring Mackinaw City, the restaurant keeps things convenient without losing that homemade feel. Coffee, beer, and a thoughtful selection of alcoholic drinks help round out the experience, making it easy to settle in for a laid-back evening with friends or family. Vegetarian options are also available, which adds flexibility for groups with different tastes and preferences.

What really makes the place stand out is the relaxed and friendly atmosphere. It feels approachable instead of overly formal, so both tourists and locals can feel comfortable enjoying classic Italian comfort food at their own pace. The onsite service adds to that easygoing experience, especially for travelers looking for a dependable restaurant after a long day near the waterfront. Between the inviting setting, flavorful Italian dishes, and casual charm, Nonna Lisa's creates the kind of dining experience people often hope to discover while visiting a small lakeside town.

Other menus in Mackinaw City

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Mackinaw City listings
Call Menu Directions